Comparison of Acapella TM Versus Flutter for Airway Clearance In COPD Patients – A Cross Over Trial
Keywords:
Acapella, Flutter, COPD, Airway Clearance, PEP devicesAbstract
Background: Mechanical devices like Acapella and Flutter , which are able to create oscillatory positive expiratory pressure (PEP) have been used to promote mucus clearance. These devices prevent airway collapse by stenting the airways to promote collateral ventilation and thus assist in removal of secretions. The objective of present study was to compare Acapella versus Flutter for airway clearance in COPD patients. Method: 10 males and 5 females diagnosed as COPD based on GOLD’s criteria and aged 45-65 years were conveniently selected from Vikhe Patil Hospital, Ahmednagar. Design: Crossover trial. Result: 30 subject were included for cross over trial. The outcome measure was sputum volume in ml to compare between Acapella and Flutter. There is significant difference (p<0.0001) in sputum volume for Acapella and Flutter where p=0.05. Conclusion: Both the devices are effective however Flutter is more effective than Acapella for airway clearance in COPD patients.
Downloads
References
Pauwels RA,Buist AS, calverley PM,Jenkins CR,Hurd SS. Global strategy for the diagnosis,management,and prevention of chronic obstructive pulmonary disease- NHLB/WHO Global Initiative for chronic obstructive Lung Disease. Am J RespirCrit care Med,2014,163(5):1256-1276.
Mary LouWarren,MSN,RN,CNS-CC,CCRN, and Sarah Livesay,BSN,RN.Taking action against acute ref COPD.December 2006 American Nurse Today Volume 1 number3.page no.10-11
Positive expiratory pressure techniques in respiratory patients: old evidence and new insights.Breathe December2009 volume 6 No2
Monika Fagevik Olsen Elisabeth Westerdahl.Positive Expiratory pressure in patients with chronic obstructive pulmonary Disease -A systematic Review Respiration 2009;77:110-118
Volsko TA, Di Fiore JM, Chatburn RL.Performance comparison of two oscillating Positive expiratory ressure devices:Axapellaversus Flutter.Respir care,2003;48:124-130.
Magdy Abu-Rayan et al.Evaluation of the single & combined roles of oscillating positive expiratory pressure device & conventional multimodality chest physiotherapy in mechanically ventulated COPD patients.Bull.Alex.Fac.med.45 No.2,2009
Low HT,Chew WT,Zhou CW.pulmonary airway reopening:Effects of non Newtonian fluid viscosity.J.Biomech Engg.1997;119(3):298308.
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 International License.
